Most of the Best Inflation Hedges Aren't for Sale

Inflation is the stealthiest and most destructive "tax" there is. Nobody sends a bill. Your balances (in dollars) may stay the same, but what they buy shrinks a little every year, which is exactly why the "safe" money in a checking account is the one asset that loses purchasing power almost every single year. When people notice, the reflex is to go shopping for protection: gold, farmland, a commodity fund, or crypto.

I'd argue most of the better hedges aren't for sale at all. Most people already own four of the five on this list, and the fifth is mostly misunderstood.

First, some definitions. In finance-speak, nominal means the number as written on the page, and real means what that number actually buys.

The whole idea

Here are keys to understanding how to "beat" inflation at its own game.

  1. Own things that pay you in real dollars
  2. Owe things you repay in nominal dollars.

A $100 bill is $100 nominal forever, but at 3 percent inflation it buys about $97 worth of groceries next year and about $74 worth in ten.

Real income grows with prices, so it keeps buying the same things. Nominal income is a fixed number, so it buys less every year. When you're the one receiving nominal dollars, inflation is working against you. When you're the one paying them, it's working for you, and that asymmetry is what we have to understand to successfully navigate inflation.

Everything below is an application of that one idea.

1. A salary that keeps up

The largest inflation-hedged asset most working people own isn't in a brokerage account. It's their career. A salary that rises with the cost of living is an income stream paid in real dollars, and for most households it dwarfs the portfolio for the first couple of decades.

The honest caveat is the word "keeps up." Wages lagged inflation badly in 2021 and 2022, and plenty of jobs never fully caught up. So this hedge isn't automatic. It's something you maintain: negotiating raises against actual inflation rather than against last year's number, investing in skills that stay in demand, and remembering that a merit increase that trails the CPI is actually a pay cut.

2. A 30-year fixed mortgage

This is the one people don't think of as an asset, because it's a debt. That's the point.

A fixed-rate mortgage is the single largest nominal obligation most families ever take on, and you repay it with dollars that get cheaper every year. Your payment in year twenty is the same number as year one, while everything around it, including your income, has inflated. The bank took the inflation risk. You got the fixed price.

There's an extra feature hiding in it. If rates fall, you can refinance. If rates rise, you keep what you have. That's an option somebody would normally charge you for, and it came free with the loan.

The caveat: it only hedges if you keep it. Paying a low fixed mortgage off early in an inflationary stretch is, in real terms, prepaying a debt that's getting cheaper on its own. That doesn't mean never pay it off; peace of mind is very real, too. It simply means understand what you're giving up. And no, this isn't a reason to buy a house you otherwise wouldn't.

(Side note: For many people, a paid-off house is immeasurably valuable to their wellbeing and happiness. If that describes you, don't let an interest rate arbitrage bro tell you otherwise! I like to jokingly describe a paid-off house as an asset that pays perpetual"psychic dividends.")

3. Delaying Social Security

This one is for those of you nearing retirement.

Social Security benefits carry an annual cost-of-living adjustment tied to inflation, and it never goes negative, which makes them one of the rare income streams designed to hold their purchasing power for life. Delaying your claim past full retirement age increases the benefit by roughly 8 percent per year until age 70, and that larger number is what the future cost-of-living adjustments compound on.

Put differently, delaying is buying more inflation-indexed lifetime income at a price set by actuaries rather than an insurance company's sales desk. Truly inflation-indexed private annuities have nearly vanished from the market, which makes this the most accessible inflation-indexed lifetime income most Americans can still get, and you get it by waiting.

The failure mode is obvious: it pays off if you live, and you need other assets to bridge the years you're not claiming. For a healthy person with a portfolio to draw on, that trade has historically been a good one, and it also insures against the risk nobody plans for, which is living a lot longer than expected.

Likewise, if you pass away before taking social security, you never got to enjoy any of that money. Still, best to consider both sides before taking SS early for no good reason.

4. Stocks, but over decades

Stocks are an inflation hedge with a time limit attached, and the time limit runs the wrong way. In the short run, an inflation shock tends to hurt them; 2022 was a reminder that stocks and bonds can fall together when prices are rising. But over long periods, companies raise prices, revenues grow with the economy, and equity returns have historically outpaced inflation by a wide margin.

So the hedge is measured in decades, not years. If you need the money in three years, stocks are likely not protecting it from anything. If you need it in twenty+, equities have historically delivered among the strongest inflation-adjusted returns available to ordinary investors, with plenty of volatility along the way. Notice the word "historically"... It's there on purpose. I wrote about why markets don't make promises in Investing Isn't Physics, and inflation is the perfect example: the hedge is statistical, not mechanical or automatic.

5. TIPS, explained

Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities are the one item on this list that's actually a product, and the only one that hedges inflation by construction rather than by tendency. They also confuse nearly everyone, so here's the version I wish someone had given me.

A TIPS is a Treasury bond whose principal adjusts with the Consumer Price Index. If inflation runs 3 percent, the bond's principal grows 3 percent, and the fixed coupon rate then pays on that larger amount. At maturity you get the inflation-adjusted principal back, or the original if prices somehow fell. The yield you see quoted is a real yield, meaning what you earn above inflation, which is why TIPS yields look oddly low next to regular Treasuries. They're not lower. They're measured in different units.

Three things trip people up.

First, the tax. That annual principal adjustment is taxed as income in the year it happens, even though you don't receive it until maturity. In a taxable account, you can owe tax on money you haven't been paid. This is why TIPS belong in an IRA or 401(k) whenever possible.

Second, the price. TIPS protect you against inflation, not against rising real yields. When real yields rose sharply in 2022, TIPS prices fell, and plenty of people who bought them as an inflation hedge watched them lose value during the highest inflation in forty years. Held to maturity, the inflation protection works exactly as designed. Sold early, you're exposed to the same interest rate risk as any bond.

Third, the fund question. A TIPS fund never matures, so it never delivers that clean end-date guarantee; it just rolls bonds forever, and its price moves with real yields indefinitely. A ladder of individual TIPS matched to the years you'll actually need the money is the purest version of the hedge, and for someone whose retirement spending is fixed in real terms, it's one of the cleanest matches between an asset and a liability in all of finance. For someone still accumulating, TIPS usually play a smaller role, because the stock and salary hedges above are doing the heavy lifting.

The retail cousin: I-bonds work on the same idea with simpler mechanics, no price risk since they don't trade, and tax deferral until you cash out. The catches are a $10,000 annual purchase limit per person, a one-year lockup, and a three-month interest penalty if you cash out within five years. Smaller hedge, no confusion.

Two hedges inside a portfolio

Two portfolio decisions do inflation work without ever being labeled hedges.

The first is how long your bonds are. Inflation punishes long bonds hardest, because a coupon locked in for twenty years has twenty years of shrinking to do, while a short-term bond matures soon and gets reinvested at whatever rates have become. The right duration for a given household depends on when the money is needed.

The second is owning stocks outside the United States. Inflation is a currency-by-currency phenomenon, and a portfolio priced entirely in dollars has all of its purchasing power tied to one country's prices. International stocks earn in other currencies and other economies, which don't move in lockstep with ours. Neither decision is dramatic. Neither decision is overly dramatic... They just sit in the portfolio and do their work whether or not inflation shows up.

Run the rule in reverse

The rule works as a diagnostic too. If real assets you own and nominal debts you owe are hedges, then nominal assets you own are exposure, and most people hold more of them than they realize. A pension without a cost-of-living adjustment. A fixed immediate annuity. A long-term CD, a thirty-year bond, the cash value inside a whole life policy. Each pays a fixed number of dollars that buys a little less every year, but none of them says so on the statement.

The point isn't to dump them. Some are exactly right for the job they were bought for. The point is to account for them correctly, so you know how much of your future income is already exposed before deciding how much hedging you need.

The flip side is a pleasant surprise for some readers. A pension with a cost-of-living adjustment, which many military and government retirees have, is one of the most valuable inflation hedges a household can own. If you have one, count it first. It changes how much of everything else you need.

About the usual suspects

Gold, commodities, and crypto often get sold as inflation hedges, and I'm not going to pretend they're worthless. Gold has some record as a store of value over very long stretches, but over the horizons a household actually plans around, all three have a losing relationship with inflation, pay nothing while you wait, and swing on sentiment far more than on the CPI. A hedge that performs unpredictably is a speculation, just with better marketing.

Every item I listed above either pays you real dollars or costs you nominal ones, by design, which is how I would define a "hedge."

The portfolio is bigger than the brokerage account

The thread running through this list is that inflation protection is mostly a design question, not a shopping question. Your career, your mortgage, your claiming age, and the horizon you give your stocks do more to protect your purchasing power than any single fund you could buy, and the one product that truly hedges works best when it's matched to a specific future dated need.


Referenced: Social Security Administration, delayed retirement credits; TreasuryDirect, TIPS and Series I bond terms.

Matthew Morris

Matt Morris, CFP®, MSFP is the founder of Multipath Wealth Management, a fee-only fiduciary financial planning and investment management firm in Columbia, South Carolina. He works virtually with clients nationwide, primarily physicians and other medical professionals in the early and middle stages of their careers. He holds degrees in mathematics, computer science, and financial planning.

Matt favors advice that is simple, tax-efficient, and easy to stick with.

https://multipathwealth.com
Next
Next

HSAs an Investment Account